There is no comparison. The BMW is worlds above the Charger. But, the BMW was 40k new, and has about 40k in mods, so it wouldn't be fair at all to compare the two. The BMW has a full Dinan Stage 3 suspension with H&R Race springs, as well as a supercharger, exhaust and throttle body upgrade. It also has a full M-Tech/Hamann body kit and the only Hamann Sport Steering wheel in the US. Plus a ton more....... I haven't gotten on the gas hard in the Charger yet, so I can't compare acceleration, but the BMW dynoed at 275 HP to the rear wheel, so they should be comparable. All the BMW HP is in the top end though, whereas the Charger has it on the bottom end. I find that the Charger does handle like a boat, which is to be expected..... actually, even my 95 BMW 525i handles better than the Charger.